Skip to content
    Call Now
    Roofing Guide6 min read

    How to Choose a Roofing Contractor (Without Getting Burned)

    Published by MCO RoofingPublished Updated Editorial policy
    AI-generated illustration of a roofing crew working on a house
    AI-generated illustration; not a photograph of an MCO project.

    Want a straight answer about your own roof?

    Free inspection, written report, no sales pitch. We cover Johnson, Douglas, Wyandotte and Leavenworth counties.

    (913) 361-5443

    We're a roofing company, so telling you how to pick a roofing company probably sounds self-serving. Fair enough. But we're also the ones who get called in to fix the work that a bad contractor left behind, and we've seen some genuinely awful stuff. Underlayment nailed on upside down. Shingles installed in the wrong direction. Flashing sealed with duct tape, actual duct tape. So yeah, this topic matters, and we'd rather you pick a good competitor than get burned by a bad one.

    Red flags that should stop you cold

    • Company identity or contact details that you cannot verify
    • Pressure to sign before you understand the scope and terms
    • An unclear payment schedule or undocumented payment requests
    • Insurance evidence that cannot be confirmed with the issuing agent
    • An offer to hide a discount or project cost from your insurer
    • A vague written scope with unresolved exclusions

    Four checks that filter out most storm chasers

    1. 1Kansas AG registrationPaid roofing contractors generally need a Kansas registration certificate unless exempt. Ask for the number and verify the current registration through the state resources.
    2. 2Local city or county licenseOverland Park, Olathe, Lenexa and Johnson County each run their own licensing. State registration alone is not enough.
    3. 3Certificate of insuranceGeneral liability plus workers compensation, sent directly by their insurance agent rather than forwarded by the salesperson.
    4. 4A local address you can drive toNot a PO box, and not an out of state number that appeared the week after the storm.
    Kansas Attorney General resources explain contractor registration and give homeowners a way to verify current registration.

    Green flags that mean you're in good hands

    • A verifiable company identity and service contact
    • Current insurance documents and credentials required for your address
    • Any claimed manufacturer certification checked with its issuer
    • Written products, scope, schedule, cleanup, warranty and payment terms
    • A clear plan for permits and inspections where required
    • Relevant references shared with customer permission
    AI-generated illustration of exposed roofing fasteners
    AI-generated illustration of exposed roofing fasteners.

    Get three bids, but don't pick the cheapest

    Compare written scopes before choosing a bid. If one price is substantially lower, ask what it includes and leaves out: product, tear-off, flashing, decking allowances, protection, cleanup and warranty terms. A lower price can reflect a leaner operation or a narrower scope. The estimate and the contractor's answers help you understand the difference.

    Compare the bids line by line. Are they using the same shingle brand and grade? Are they including underlayment, ice and water shield, drip edge, ridge vent? Is cleanup and debris removal included? Is there a workmanship warranty on top of the manufacturer warranty? The details matter more than the bottom line number.

    We're happy to be one of your three bids. Give us a call at (913) 361-5443 and we'll put together a detailed estimate you can compare against anyone else's.

    Want a straight answer about your own roof?

    Free inspection, written report, no sales pitch. We cover Johnson, Douglas, Wyandotte and Leavenworth counties.

    (913) 361-5443
    Back to all guides

    Request a roof inspection

    Free inspections across the Kansas City metro, in Kansas and Missouri.

    First responder & veteran credit: see eligibility and terms
    (913) 361-5443