Skip to content
    Call Now
    Materials5 min read

    Asphalt vs. Metal Roofing: Which Is Right for Your Kansas Home?

    Two solid options, two very different price tags. Here's an honest breakdown of what works, and what doesn't, in Kansas weather.

    Published by MCO RoofingPublished Updated Editorial policy
    Side-by-side comparison of asphalt shingle and metal roofing

    Want a straight answer about your own roof?

    Free inspection, written report, no sales pitch. We cover Johnson, Douglas, Wyandotte and Leavenworth counties.

    (913) 361-5443

    We get this question at least once a week: should I go with asphalt or metal? Both are good choices for Kansas homes, but they solve different problems. Here's the honest breakdown. No sales pitch.

    Asphalt shinglesMetal roofing
    Roof coveringOverlapping individual shinglesPanels or metal shingles; specify the system
    AppearanceFlat or layered shingle profilesRaised seams or other panel and shingle profiles
    Installation scopeStarter, field and ridge shingles; underlayment and flashingPanel layout, clips or fasteners, trim, underlayment and flashing
    Repair planningCheck compatibility and availability of replacement shinglesCheck panel access, seam details and compatible replacement parts
    Documents to compareExact shingle tests, required accessories and written warrantyExact system tests, attachment details and written warranty
    Asphalt vs. metal roofing for Kansas homes

    Asphalt shingles: the workhorse

    Asphalt shingles come in flat three-tab and layered architectural styles, with several product lines within each category. Compare the exact shingle, underlayment, flashing and ventilation in the estimate. Ask which accessories and installation methods are required for the proposed warranty.

    Hail and wind can damage asphalt shingles. During an inspection, we look at the observed condition of the shingles and surrounding details, including flashing and penetrations. Roof age and the shingle's product label alone do not establish whether repair or replacement is appropriate.

    A roof, from the outside in

    Outside

    1. ShinglesSheds water, takes the hail hits
    2. UnderlaymentSynthetic sheet, second line of defense
    3. Ice and water shieldSealed membrane at the eaves and valleys
    4. Roof deckThe plywood everything nails into
    5. Vented atticAir has to keep moving through here

    Inside your home

    A roof is a system. When one layer fails, the ones under it start doing a job they were never designed for.

    Metal roofing: the long game

    Standing-seam metal roofing uses panels with raised seams and product-specific attachment details. Compare the finish, fastening system, flashing and maintenance instructions. If insurance pricing is part of your decision, ask your insurer for a written quote tied to the exact product. No discount is guaranteed.

    A standing-seam estimate needs to account for panel layout, attachments, transitions and flashing. Compare it with the complete asphalt scope for your roof. Ask the contractor about experience with the proposed metal system and how damaged panels or details would be repaired.

    Standing seam metal roof panel sample
    Standing-seam metal panel detail.

    The Kansas weather factor

    Compare the published wind and impact information for each proposed system, including installation conditions and exclusions. A laboratory classification does not predict every storm's effect on your home. Rain noise also depends on the complete assembly, including decking and insulation.

    Our take

    Ask for a side-by-side written scope for the asphalt and metal options suited to your roof. Compare the price, appearance, maintenance, repairability and separate workmanship and manufacturer warranties. Call (913) 361-5443 to discuss the measurements and condition of your property.

    Questions we get asked

    Rain and hail noise depend on the panel system, decking, insulation and the rooms below. Ask about the complete proposed assembly and its acoustic characteristics; the material name alone cannot establish how it will sound indoors.

    A roof covering alone does not establish a home's lightning risk or provide a complete lightning-protection system. Ask a qualified lightning-protection professional about the building and any protection requirements; do not select a roof on a claim that metal makes the home lightning-proof.

    Insurance pricing varies by carrier, policy, product and installation record. Give your insurer the exact product specification and ask for a written quote before treating any possible discount as part of the budget.

    An overlay depends on the existing roof and deck condition, structural capacity, the new product's installation instructions and the requirements at the property address. Ask the local permit authority and contractor to confirm the proposed assembly before approving work.

    Want a straight answer about your own roof?

    Free inspection, written report, no sales pitch. We cover Johnson, Douglas, Wyandotte and Leavenworth counties.

    (913) 361-5443
    Back to all guides

    Request a roof inspection

    Free inspections across the Kansas City metro, in Kansas and Missouri.

    First responder & veteran credit: see eligibility and terms
    (913) 361-5443